What is peanut butter whiskey?

Flavored whiskeys have been around for a bit, and they’re pretty dang tasty. We love vanilla flavored, mable bourbon and chocolate to name a few. There’s a new flavored whiskey on the rise these days, inspired by America’s sweetheart - peanut butter. That’s right folks, peanut butter whiskey is here to stay. So we’re breaking down what the heck it is and what peanut butter whiskeys Drizly shoppers have dubbed worth the hype.

This will depend on the brand you’re sipping. Some make a regular whiskey with corn and barley, then add a mix of flavorings to get that peanut buttery goodness, others simply infuse the two. Either way, the recipe is up for interpretation. The point here though is to get a beverage that tastes like, well, peanut butter. 

One of the first in the peanut butter whiskey space, Skrewball is a well renowned peanut butter whiskey from California. Creamy on the nose, this peanut butter whiskey is beloved by many for its peanut butter-hazelnut flavor. If you’re feeling nostalgic, add a little Chambord and make an adult PB&J cocktail.

Aroma: creamy with hints of peanut butter and caramel. The creaminess has a hint of irish cream scent.
Taste: Super sweet. Solid creaminess and pretty strong essence of peanut butter. Overall a solid addition to a boozy coffee or hot chocolate if you feel like you want a sweet peanut butter kick.
ABV: 35%

Hailing from Kentucky - this peanut butter whiskey combines whiskey and peanut butter into one liquor that isn’t overpowering on either end. Don’t just listen to us though.

Customer Review: “I was impressed. Skeptical at first, but later impressed! It’s got a pleasant peanut butter sweetness to it and given some creativity can be excellent in mixed drinks. It really shines neat though, and makes for something nice to sip on for those with a sweet tooth.” 
ABV: 35%

Another contender from Kentucky - this is a bold whiskey with warmth compliments of the PB.

*Very Excited* Customer Review: “PEANUT BUTTER RAMS & SMIRNOFF GRAPE VODKA MADE PB&J SHOTS..:fire::fire::fire:”
ABV: 35%

99 Peanut Butter Whiskey is a recent release from the brand. They say it’s an intense drink experience with extreme flavor and energy, and they are NOT kidding around. First things first - this product comes in a shot size bottle (1.5oz) only. With a strong aroma and taste of peanut butter followed by a taste of vanilla and heat from whiskey - this one packs a bunch. A great option for cocktails, but be warned -  99 Brand makes 99 proof liquor. Tread lightly.

ABV: 49.5%

With an aroma of freshly roasted peanuts, a taste true to peanut butter and a finish with the sweetness of butterscotch and roasted peanuts - SQRRL is bound to become a PB whiskey favorite.

Customer review: “This is by far my favorite of the Peanut Butter Whiskies. Well balanced and delicious flavors of roasted peanut butter with hints of caramel and chocolate notes.”
ABV: 35%

There you have it, friends. Our PB whiskey knowledge is now yours. Happy sipping!